News & Resources

Superior Court Denies Effort to Require State to Intervene in School Districts to Ensure Meaningful Instructional Time

Apr 21, 2015 | Legal Developments and News

Plaintiffs in Cruz v. State of California, et al., are students attending schools in California including Los Angeles Unified School District, Oakland Unified School District and Compton Unified School District. These students, represented by ACLU and Public Counsel, filed a motion for preliminary injunction seeking an order requiring the State to take action to ensure that each of the six high schools identified in the motion provides “meaningful instruction” during all periods of the school day and timely prepares the master schedule. The court found that plaintiffs failed to establish a statewide standard for the use of what  plaintiffs referred to as “non-instructional” periods, such as home and/or service periods, or for the preparation of master schedules. The evidence of statewide standard offered by plaintiffs in the form of declarations from ten school districts across the state was insufficient to show that the six schools are offering plaintiffs an educational program that falls below any statewide standard. Absent such evidence, there is no basis to provide the requested relief.

This is  not the final  determination of the issues in this case but we note that any ruling regarding a “statewide standard” for provision of meaningful instructional time is likely to have statewide impacts. We will continue to apprise you of developments as this case moves forward.

To discuss this case further, or if you have any questions, please contact
Sue Ann Salmon Evans.

RELATED POSTS

2023 Legislative and Case Law Highlights – K-12 School Districts

2023 Legislative and Case Law Highlights – K-12 School Districts

Countdown to the Bond Part 2 – January 2024

Are You Considering a March or November 2024 Bond Election? Now is the Time to Begin Preparing Your Ballot Measure! Countdown to the Bond is a multi-part series of legal...

Adjusted Bid Thresholds for Contracts Effective January 1, 2024

Effective January 1, 2024, the bid threshold for contracts awarded by school districts competitively bid pursuant to Public Contract Code (PCC) section 20111(a) increased from $109,300 to $114,500 (link available here)....